By Jeff Sparrow*
Collected Poems: Lesbia Harford
by Oliver Dennis (editor)
UWA Publishing
152pp
$29.99AU
Published September, 2014
ISBN 9781742585352
When Lesbia Harford died in 1927, she left behind three thick and neatly-lined exercise books full of handwritten poetry. These, now housed in the Mitchell Library, provided the basis for Nettie Palmer’s The Poems of Lesbia Harford (1941) and, in 1985, Drusilla Modjeska and Marjorie Pizer’s expanded collection, published under the same title.
Now we have a new and even more comprehensive edition, courtesy of Oliver Dennis and UWA Press. In his introduction to Collected Poems, Dennis writes:
Of the nearly four hundred poems in manuscript, just over half that number are reproduced here; of these, a third or so … have not, to my knowledge appeared in print previously.
Bringing so much writing by an important but under-appreciated Australian poet into the public arena is a major achievement, for which both editor and publisher should be congratulated. It is, however, regrettable that the new volume diminishes Harford’s work with an editorial framing that feels unpleasantly gendered.
Much of what we know about Harford’s life comes from research conducted by Pizer, a former Communist Party member personally acquainted with some of Harford’s circle. Dennis bases his introduction almost exclusively upon this material, ignoring, for instance, Ann Vickery’s recent study in Stressing the Modern (2007). Perhaps lacking Pizer and Modjeska’s political sympathies, he interprets it in ways that are frustrating and tendentious. For example, he writes:
Whereas many poets of the time – Mary Gilmore or Banjo Paterson, for example – wrote with an eye to establishing an Australian literature, Harford clearly never gave a moment’s thought to abstract notions of culture or nationhood … She instead found her place out of view, where she was free to articulate a distinctive brand of pure, incidental song.
To Koskino 